Transportation Brief: Eleventh Circuit Upholds Downstream Carrier’s Limitation of Liability
May 22, 2018
Barrett Moving & Storage (Barrett) was asked to transport two truckloads of equipment from Illinois to Texas. Barrett moved one truckload and retained Landstar under a broker/carrier agreement to move the other. When the goods in the second truck were damaged, the shipper’s insurer sued both carriers. Landstar moved to enforce the limitation of liability in its bill of lading. The District Court rejected Landstar’s limitation, holding that Barrett’s agreement with the shipper, which contained no limitation, was binding on Landstar. The Eleventh Circuit, in Essex Insurance v. Barrett Moving & Storage, reversed summary judgment against Landstar by upholding standing law that shippers are bound by liability limitations established between an intermediary and a carrier, notwithstanding the shipper’s claim that it was not aware that Barrett brokered the load. The Court further held that it is the initial carrier, not the unknowing downstream carrier, that bears the burden of expanded liability to the shipper.
Scopelitis’ Transportation Brief® is intended as a report to our clients and friends on developments affecting the transportation industry. The published material does not constitute an exhaustive legal study and should not be regarded or relied upon as individual legal advice or opinion.
Transportation Brief: My Driver Filed an Unemployment Claim Where? Jurisdiction as a Defense to State Unemployment Claims and Worker Misclassification Challenges
by Steven A. Pletcher , Rebecca S. TrennerDetermining where to report unemployment tax is not only important for employee fleets, but it is also an important potential tool for defending state unemployment tax worker misclassification challenges. Read more here.
Transportation Brief: Buyers Be Diligent
by Gregory M. Feary , Kathryne S. Feary-Gardner , Jay D. Robinson,When considering the acquisition of a motor carrier operation, a number of due diligence matters specific to transportation should be analyzed. Read more here.
Transportation Brief: Full Enforcement of the ELD Mandate Commences
Previously, ELD violations, though listed on roadside inspection reports and sometimes prompting fines, did not result in out-of-service orders or negatively impact a motor carrier’s Safety Measurement System (SMS) scores. Now, drivers who are subject to the ELD mandate and found to be operating without a device will be placed out of service for 10 hours. Read more here.
Transportation Brief: Warehouse Chargebacks
by Caroline D. Milner , Kevin M. PhillipsChargebacks are most common in the retail industry, but they have application in other industries as well. Read more here.
Transportation Brief: Spotlight on Unemployment Tax Practice
by Steven A. Pletcher , Rebecca S. TrennerState unemployment tax remains one of many misclassification battlefronts for motor carriers and other transportation companies utilizing equipment or services provided by independent contractors (IC). Members of Scopelitis' Unemployment Tax team offers a unique set of experiences and thought leadership regarding these matters. Read more here.
Transportation Brief: For the Record Spring 2018
We are pleased to announce that Michael Reed has joined the Firm’s Chicago office. Michael joins the Personal Injury, Property Damage, and Cargo Claims practice group.
- On the Road
Scopelitis attorneys are often invited to participate in meetings with transportation industry leaders. Learn more about their trips this quarter.
Transportation Industry News & Trends