Transportation Brief: Ninth Circuit Addresses Piece-rate Pay Plans

by James H. Hanson, E. Ashley Paynter

August 25, 2021

Plaintiffs’ lawyers have long argued that under California law, drivers paid with a mileage-based compensation formula are not compensated for their non-driving activities, such as time spent conducting pre-trip and post-trip inspections, fueling, waiting at company terminals, waiting at customer locations, and completing paper work associated with a load. As a result, plaintiffs’ lawyers contend that employers must compensate drivers for performing those tasks separately from the pay they receive from their mileage-based compensation formula.

Notwithstanding such arguments, in Ayala v. U.S. Xpress, Inc., the Ninth Circuit recently ruled that a properly drafted piece-rate compensation pay plan that pays for delivered loads can cover both the time spent driving as well as the time spent performing non-driving activities associated with delivering the loads.

It is important to have a written compensation pay plan to address how drivers earn their activity-based pay.

• Transportation Brief: Labor Meets Transportation in Surface Transportation Reauthorization Bills
  by Gregory M. Feary , Prasad Sharma
  
  Congress is making progress, albeit in fits and starts, towards passing a multiyear surface transportation reauthorization bill. Both versions of these massive bills not only authorize highway spending, but also contain numerous policy-related provisions aimed at trucking. While the future of the legislation and the final provisions are uncertain, now is a good time to look at what may be coming down the road.
• Transportation Brief: Collections During COVID and Beyond – Protecting Your Warehouse
  by Kevin  M. Phillips , Michael  D. Reed
  
  During the height of the pandemic, businesses, including warehouses, were presented with a new world of challenges. One such challenge present before and during the pandemic is collections. The good news is that warehouses can take certain actions to be better positioned to handle this age-old problem. 
• Transportation Brief: Questions Remain After Change in Export Air Cargo Rules
  by Braden K. Core , Nathaniel G. Saylor
  
  In the Spring 2021 edition of The Transportation Brief, we advised on an upcoming change to the rules governing cargo offered for international air transportation. The new rule, effective June 30, 2021, requires all cargo to be screened or handled pursuant to an “alternative framework.” This has caused significant disruption in the supply chain as shippers, air forwarders, and all-cargo aircraft operators attempt to navigate new compliance obligations.  Read more about these difficulties and how to stay ahead of the curve.
• Transportation Brief: New Texas Law Paving the Way to Curbing Nuclear Verdicts
  by Renea E. Hooper , Peter C. Morton
  
  With “runaway” jury verdicts in trucking accident cases on the rise in recent years, a new law may give trucking companies some relief in one major venue.
• Transportation Brief: Spotlight on Investigations and Audits
  Kelli M. Block , Braden K. Core , Gregory M. Feary , A. Jack Finklea , James H. Hanson , Christopher C. McNatt , Steven A. Pletcher , David D. Robinson , Nathaniel G. Saylor , Rebecca S. Trenner
  
  While the transportation industry is largely deregulated, a surprising number of federal, state, and local government agencies write and administer a long—and growing—list of rules affecting transportation providers. These agencies regularly inspect for noncompliance, and they have the power to assess civil penalties for violations, place assets “out of service,” or worse. When the inspectors come calling, it is important to be prepared.
• On the Road
  Scopelitis attorneys are often invited to participate in meetings with transportation industry leaders. Learn more about their trips this quarter.
• Dispatches
  Transportation Industry News & Trends